Mongabay Biotopes
Shrimp
Oliver Knott's Planted Tank Pages
AGA Aquascaping Tanks
Chuck Gadd's Planted Tank Pages
FINS:APD,Killitalk
Tropica Aquatic Nursury in Denmark
Cryptocorynes
The Krib, home of the *.aquaria FAQs
Plant Geek
Plant Geek
Planted Tank
Hoa Nguyen Low-Tech Tanks
Wet Web Media
The Barr Report

Killifish
Cryptocorynes
Apple snails - Applesnail.NET
Catfish - Planet Catfish
FINS:APD:Killitalk
Rainbowfish - Home of the Rainbowfish
Fish Species - Fishbase
Plant Species - Tropica, Denmark
The Krib
Loaches - Loaches.COM
Cichlids - Cichlids.COM

   Articles  
  DIY  
  Plants  
  Chemistry  
  Lighting  
  Filter  
  Collecting  
  Meds  
    Antibiotics  
      Warning  
        Wright  
        Harro  
        Phage  
        Montefiorense  
        Bass  
        Chickens  
        Species  
        Herbal  
        Slashdot  
        Sterling  
        MRSA  
        Ganoderma  
      Alternatives  
      Gram  
    Disease  
    Bibliography  
  Fish  
  Glass  
  Buying  
  Random  
  Disease  
  Biology  
Chemistry  
Biology  
Physics  
Lighting  
Water  
Fish  
Plants  
Hw  
Sw  
Images  
Lists  
Users  
News  
Credits  
2010  
2011  
Ebooks  
Calculators  
Aquarium Antibiotics Considered Harmful


Aquarium Antibiotics Considered Harmful

I contracted "fishkeeper's finger" (aka "swimmer's granuloma", "fish tuberculosis" or "FT") a few years ago. Mycobacterium marinum is common to most tanks [Ed note: it is estimates that 95-100% of wild fish carry the pathogen], but a dreadful infection to get. This is also known as "Fish TB" as it actually is a variety of tuberculosis.

Failure to use antibiotics to get 100% cures has enabled this bug to become resistant to all but three known (very expensive) antibiotics. I took 2 Biaxin pills a day for over 6 months to get it down to where my immune system could finish the job. Figure it out at $6 per pill!

Beside causing severe pain in my wallet, the damned stuff gave me hideous ulceration on the infected finger, and swollen lymph nodes (with severe pain) all up my right arm. One just below my elbow was the size of a walnut and located exactly where you rest your arm to type or do anything at the workbench.

IMHO, there are no circumstances, even for a $50,000 Koi, that justify the use of tetracycline, erythromycin, or any other broad-range (kill everything) antibiotic on fish. You usually cannot dose them adequately through the water, only by injection. [Even most vets don't know how to do that correctly.] The bug you may not completely kill is usually not the one you diagnose, but a quiet bystander in the aquarium water -- like my Fish TB was.

Antibiotics will not end a sore throat more quickly (except maybe by placebo effect) and can't kill any known virus. Using too little, or for too short a time, just creates resistant bugs. In a given situation, only a trained MD or vet will get it right, and a lot of them don't. [I once knew an alcoholic MD who prescribed tetracycline for every patient he saw. Didn't matter what their problem was, as he was worthless as a diagnostician, so he just gave it to them for anything from a sprain to a headache. GRRRR!]

May anyone who uses erythromycin to kill blue-green algae ("BGA") have a trip to the hospital where they get the resistant forms of staph or some other flesh-melting germ. IMNSHO, that's exactly what they deserve for such irresponsibility.

BGA is trivially easy to cure, without producing any more resistant *Staphylococcus aureus*

Wright Huntley




Site Sponsor

Mercedes Parts
Mongabay Biotopes
Shrimp
Oliver Knott's Planted Tank Pages
AGA Aquascaping Tanks
Chuck Gadd's Planted Tank Pages
FINS:APD,Killitalk
Tropica Aquatic Nursury in Denmark
Cryptocorynes
The Krib, home of the *.aquaria FAQs
Plant Geek
Plant Geek
Planted Tank
Hoa Nguyen Low-Tech Tanks
Wet Web Media
The Barr Report

Killifish
Cryptocorynes
Apple snails - Applesnail.NET
Catfish - Planet Catfish
FINS:APD:Killitalk
Rainbowfish - Home of the Rainbowfish
Fish Species - Fishbase
Plant Species - Tropica, Denmark
The Krib
Loaches - Loaches.COM
Cichlids - Cichlids.COM